Who's Which?

About This Movie

Who's Which? is a curious little short from 1925 that captures that raw essence of slapstick comedy. Directed by Jules White, it features Phil Dunham’s physical humor, which is quite engaging, though it has the usual feel of early silent shorts. The pacing zigzags—some bits fly by while others linger a bit too long, creating a unique rhythm. The practical effects, typical of the era, have that charming, handmade quality that you just don’t see nowadays. It's one of those films that, while not groundbreaking, gives you a solid glimpse into the comedic style of the time and how they used absurdity to connect with audiences. You can see the roots of future comedic styles emerging here.

This film has seen limited releases, often found in collections of silent short comedies. It’s not overly common, but it pops up in various archives and festivals focused on early cinema. The scarcity factor does pique collectors' interest, especially those keen on the evolution of slapstick. Given its age and niche appeal, it's a nice conversation starter among enthusiasts who appreciate the charm of silent films.